Lookalikes

Grand fir or noble fir?

Both are big firs from the Pacific coast of North America.

The quickest check

The quickest check is the shoot from above. Grand fir: combed flat into two rows either side. Noble fir: curving up over it, hiding the twig. No leaves on the tree? Check the cones high up.

At a glance

Look atGrand firNoble fir
Shoot from aboveCombed flat into two rows either sideCurving up over it, hiding the twig
Cones high upSmooth, about 8 cm longUp to 25 cm, covered in papery flaps

Two ways to tell them apart

Shoot from aboveLeaves
Grand fir: shoot from above
Grand firCombed flat into two rows either side
Noble firCurving up over it, hiding the twig
Cones high upCones
Grand firSmooth, about 8 cm long
Noble firUp to 25 cm, covered in papery flaps
Think you can tell them apart now? Try the tree quiz: real photographs, and what gives each tree away.Take the quiz

The two trees

Grand fir

Abies grandis

Grand fir is a conifer with glossy needles that lie flat in two rows either side of the shoot. Rubbed, they smell of tangerine peel. In many districts it is the tallest tree.

How to identify grand fir →

Noble fir

Abies procera

Noble fir is a narrow, bluish grey conifer. Its needles curve up over the shoot, packed so close they hide the twig. High up, huge cones stand upright on the branches.

How to identify noble fir →
In the app

See them side by side in Treely

  • Both trees, part by partLeaves, bark, buds, flowers and fruit, photographed through the year
  • Every lookalike side by sideThe checks that settle it, for every pair people mix up
  • A short round each dayUntil you can tell them apart at a glance
  • The full GuideBoth trees written up in full, with where to find them
App StoreGoogle Play

Free to download.

Every fact on this page is checked against the Collins Tree Guide, last in November 2026. Spotted something that looks wrong in front of a real tree? Tell us. How we check.

Photographs: Harry Podschwit (CC BY 4.0), James H. Thomas (CC BY 4.0), rockybajada (CC0), David Anderson (CC BY 4.0), Jonathan Curley (CC BY 4.0). With thanks to everyone who shares their photographs on iNaturalist and Wikimedia Commons.